2. THE TRIAL

John 18:12-27
(click to read the references)

The Holy Spirit’s purpose in inspiring John to write his version of Jesus’ trial is to contrast the glory of Jesus against the sinfulness of mankind. If you think about it, the basics of Christianity is built upon the fact that Jesus Christ is the visible manifestation of the glory of God, who came to earth to redeem sinful mankind. The only reason why we are here this morning is to give thanks to God for saving us through the death of his only son, the Lord Jesus Christ.

As we look at Jesus’ trial, we need to keep in mind that it is not a minor detail in his journey to the cross. It is the means that God used to ensure that Jesus would go Calvary, where he became sin for us so that we might become the righteousness of God in him. Let’s begin our second leg of Jesus’ journey to the cross, his trial, by looking first of all at the multitude that had come out to arrest him--v. 12.

In them we see a snapshot of how the rejection of the Lord Jesus is not simply something the Jews did. But it is something that crosses all boundaries of race & social status. Because within this multitude you have Gentiles & Jews, servants & soldiers, and heathen & religious people. And though they may not have much in common, the one thing they all have in common is that they all are guilty of rejecting Jesus, which is the only sin that will keep us out of heaven. It is said that the only level ground on earth, the only place where all of mankind is equal, is at the foot of the cross. For there we all stand as sinners.

And they give us a good illustration of how sin blinds our mind to the reality of who Jesus really is. This group of people have not been moved an inch by one of the most powerful miracles in all of history when Jesus restored Malchus’ ear. Neither were they moved by the fact that they have just been given the privilege of seeing the glory of God as Jesus revealed himself to them as God. That’s because their hearts were so hardened by sin that they refused to believe what they had just seen.

This helps us to understand how Satan uses the affects of sin to dull our senses to the Spirit’s call to give our hearts to the lordship of Jesus Christ. Paul tells us that “The God of this world has blinded the mind of them that believe not, lest the light of the glorious gospel of Christ should shine unto them.” (2 Cor. 2:4) The blinding power of sin is clearly manifested by those who rejected Jesus that night. John goes on to tell us that this group of people then took Jesus to Annas--v. 13.

There is a good reason that Jesus was lead first to Annas. Annas had served many years earlier as the high priest. And the Jews believed that the office of high priest was a position for life. But the Romans wanted to control this important office, so they selected an ‘official’ high priest. Even though Annas had not been the official high priest for many years, he still had much influence. So much, that the next 7 high priests that were appointed by Rome to be the high priest, were 5 of his sons, his grandson, and his son-in-law, Caiaphas.

Not only did Annas still play a major role in the Jewish religious system, he was also in charge of the Temple concession booths that were set up in the Court of the Gentiles. Some of the booths were used to exchange the animals that could be used for sacrifices. The other booths were used to exchange the money the Jews put in the offering boxes located throughout the Temple.

According to the Old Testament, any animal used for a sacrifice had to be without any kind of spot or blemish. And when the people would come to Jerusalem, to make their sacrifices, they would bring their own animals. But before the animals could be used, they had to pass an inspection by some of Annas’ men. Who of course made sure that they found something wrong with them. The only thing the people could do, if they wanted to make a sacrifice, was to trade their animals in for an animal that had been approved for sacrifice. And since the price of the approved sacrifice had been greatly over-inflated, the people had to come up with the rest of the money.

Along with monopolizing the market on the animal sacrifices, Annas also controlled the money that was used for exchange purposes as well. At this time, many of the Jews lived throughout the world. And when the came to Jerusalem they would bring the currency of the place where they lived. Annas had made it so they couldn’t use foreign money. So the people werer forced to exchange their money for Temple money. Which of course was also highly inflated. I came across an article that said the rate of exchange was 5:1. So we see that Annas was making a fortune by extortion.

The reason it is so important for us to know this is that twice Jesus came and messed with Annas’ operation. When Jesus first began his public ministry, he chased all the money changers out of the courtyard. And he did it again 3 1/2 yrs. later, after he entered into Jerusalem on the first Palm Sunday.

Obviously this did not make Jesus very popular with Annas. So if the Jewish leaders wanted to get a quick indictment against Jesus, who better to take Jesus to then Annas? After all, since Annas hated Jesus, surely he would be the one who could quickly, and quietly, have him put to death. John also makes mention of Caiaphas--v. 14

What John tells us in this verse is important to know. One of the criticisms against the movie The Passion is that it portrays the Jews as being responsible for killing Jesus. Now we know that Jesus’ death was God’s plan that had been established in eternity past. But John is showing us that there is one person who was working overtime, who was working behind the scenes, to kill Jesus. This person is the one who manipulated all the circumstances to ensure that Jesus was put to death. And that person was none other than Caiaphas.

Caiaphas knew that he was merely a political puppet. He knew that he could be taken out of office anytime the Romans wanted to replace him. So Caiaphas was scared to death that Jesus might cause him to lose his job. When Jesus started his public ministry, the people flocked to him in mass numbers. Jesus had become very popular, very quickly. Remember that less than a week from this night, the majority of the inhabitants of Jerusalem had come out to greet Jesus. And as he made his Triumphal Entry into the city, the people were crying out, “Hosanna to the son of David: Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord. Hosanna in the highest.” (Matthew 21:9)

Caiaphas felt so threatened by Jesus that earlier he met with the other religious leaders and stated that the best thing that could happen to the nation of Israel was for Jesus to die. The only reason Caiaphas said that was because he was afraid that Jesus would start a revolution, which would cause the Romans to crack down on the nation of Israel. And if this happened, it might cause Caiaphas to lose his job because he couldn’t control the Jews. And just like his father-in-law, Caiaphas hated Jesus. So he too was ready to get rid of Jesus. Both of these men had the motive to murder Jesus. The only problem was how could they do it without being guilty of murder. And the way they did it was to have an illegal trial--v. 19.

Now according to Jewish law, just like in our legal system, a person was innocent until proven guilty. And when a person was brought to trial for an offense worthy of death, he couldn’t testify against himself. The Jews had something like our 5th Amendment, except the person was forbidded from condemning themself by his/her own words. The evidence had to be presented from other witnesses. Therefore, Annas had no right to ask Jesus anything at all.

The reason Annas asked Jesus about his disciples & his doctrine was because he was trying to get Jesus to incriminate himself. He was hoping he could get Jesus to talk about a how he & his disciples were going to overthrow the Roman government. Or he hoped that he could trap Jesus by having him teach some heresy. For if Jesus did either one of these 2 things he could be put to death. Two of the crimes that carried the death penalty in those days were being a revolutionary or being a heretic.

But the real question is not who is Jesus’ disciples, or what is Jesus’ doctrine, but rather who do you say Jesus is? Is he a liar? Is he a lunatic? Or is Jesus Lord? That is the question which Annas avoided.

People do not mind talking about Jesus Christ. Since The Passion has been released there has been much talk about Jesus. But have you noticed how quickly the subject is changed when the reason for Jesus’ death is brought into the picture. People are talking about the violence of the film, but they don’t want to talk about why Jesus had to suffer.

For when a sinner is confronted with the reality that the sins he/she committed is what caused Jesus to endure what he did, it is just too much for the sinful mind to endure. So to avoid facing the consequences of their sin, sinners will put up smoke screens. Annas focused on the sinful behaviors of Jesus’ disciples, who had all deserted him. And he focused on the differences of opinions that Jesus had concerning what the Law stated.

What Annas did is what sinners still do today. Many people reject the claim of Jesus because of the hypocrisy they see in those who claim to be followers of Jesus. And the fighting that has gone on between the different denominations, over differences of doctrines, has also hurt the cause of Christ.

I’m not trying to excuse the sinfulness of Christians, or trivialize the seriousness of the division that is within the body of Christ. But neither one of these things gives someone the right to reject Jesus and still expect to get into heaven. Please don’t tell God that you refused to believe in Jesus just because those who claim to be followers of Jesus don’t always live like Jesus. Whether you were baptized as a baby or as an adult is not what will get you into heaven. It’s not whether or not you speak in tongues that secures you a place in heaven. God is not even going to ask you what translation of the Bible you read.

The only thing that matters is what did you do with Jesus. And what you did with the knowledge of who Jesus Christ is, will either get you into heaven, or condemn you to hell. The only evidence that we will be judged on is did we accept or reject Jesus as Lord.

The response of Jesus shows us that he knows that this is an illegal trial--v. 20-21.

As I said earlier, there were certain laws in Judaism regarding someone being tried in court, especially for capital offenses. Not only could he not be forced to incriminate himself, but there had to be two or more witnesses who would testify against the man before he could be found guilty. And another law stated that the trial couldn’t be held at night. But Annas knew that Jesus was so popular, that the only way to convict him was to have an illegal trail.

Now Jesus isn’t being rebellious here. Jesus just wants to make sure that everybody there knew that this was an illegal trial. He wants it to be on public record so that all will know that he is innocent. In Annas’ attempt to discredit Jesus, in reality he was fulfilling the prophecy that said “They hated Me without a cause.” (John 15:25, Psalm 35:19, Psalm 69:4) Annas is so blinded by his hatred of Jesus that he couldn’t even see that he was proving that Jesus is the promised Messiah.

However, Jesus’ response wasn’t received very well--v. 22

The Greek words that are used here indicates that Jesus was struck across the side of his face with a club. Once again John is showing us that Jesus is not a victim, but the victor. Little did that policeman know that the moment he hit Jesus, he too proved that Jesus was the Messiah. For Micah prophesied that “They will strike the judge of Israel with a rod on the cheek.” (Micah 5:1) Despite that the fact that not only is it cruel to hit a prisoner, but it was also illegal to do so, Jesus doesn’t respond with anger. He didn’t become violent in response to being violently and illegally hit, which he had the right to do.

Instead he responds calmly to show that he still is in complete control--v. 23

This is not the normal response people would have given. If you hit me for no reason, I promise you that I will hit you back 3 different ways: fast, hard, and continuously. Now don’t pick up your rocks to throw at me, for you would do the same thing. That’s because there is within our nature a desire for self-preservation, and a sinful desire to get even.

But to further prove the sinlessness of Jesus, he didn’t get mad, he didn’t get even. At this moment, if he had wanted to, he could have called down a legion of God’s angels. And we know that an angel of the Lord, all by himself, wiped out 185,000 highly trained soldiers. So if Jesus had wanted to, he could have called for his guardian angels, and they would have wiped out the entire population of the earth. If he had done that, then he never would have had to endure the suffering that was about to be inflicted upon him. But he didn’t, because “God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved.” (John 3:17)

The whole trial exposes the hatred that was in the religious leaders’ hearts towards their Messiah. For months they had been plotting and scheming to arrest Jesus. They decided his guilt before ever trying Him. So they tried him at an illegal hour, and in an illegal way, all in an attempt to get some criminal statement that was worthy of death. But even when Jesus didn’t do what they wanted him to do, because of the intensity of their hatred towards Jesus, instead of letting him go, they continued their illegal pursuit to murder him--v. 24.

John doesn’t give us any details of what happened when Jesus stood before Caiaphas. But in the other gospels we learn what happened in this phase of Jesus’ trial. Though they found witnesses who would testify against Jesus.

But when they came forward to accuse Jesus, they contradicted what the others had said. So in sheer desperation Caiaphas finally asks Jesus, “Are You the Christ, the Son of the Blessed One? Jesus said, ‘I am, and you will see me, the Son of Man, sitting at God's right hand in the place of power and coming back on the clouds of heaven.’” (Mark 14:61-62) That was all they needed to find Jesus guilty of blasphemy, which made him a heretic. And this was a crime they could put Jesus to death for committing.

This is where every detail of the trial is essential. The Jews had no ability to put anyone to death by crucifixion. They could only put people to death by stoning. So why didn’t they stone Jesus, which was their penalty for committing heresy?

First of all, Jesus had to be crucified to prove that he was the Messiah. He had to die a death that fulfilled all the spoken & typical prophecies of the Old Testament. Jesus was aware of this. We see this when before he made his Triumphal entry into Jerusalem, Jesus took his disciples aside and said, “Behold, we are going up to Jerusalem; and the Son of Man will be delivered to the chief priests and scribes, and they will condemn Him to death, and will deliver Him to the Gentiles to mock and scourge and crucify Him, and on the third day he will be raised up.” (Matt. 20:18-19)

The other reason that Annas & Caiaphas didn’t want Jesus to be stoned to death was because they wanted to make sure that all the people knew that Jesus was accursed of God. For in the Old Testament it says that “Anyone who is hung on a tree is under God’s curse.” (Deuteronomy 21:23) But to arrange for Jesus to be crucified was not an easy thing. In order for that to happen, Jesus would have to be found guilty by Pilate. Which is what we will look at next week.

That’s the illegal trial of Jesus. But since the Holy Spirit inspired John to include the story of what was going on with Peter, it must be an important part of Jesus’ journey to the cross. So let’s look briefly at what Peter was doing while Jesus was being tried--v. 15-18, 25-26.

After the fiasco in the garden, I can’t believe that once again Peter is putting himself in harm’s way. As long as Peter tried to follow Jesus in the flesh he was no match for temptation. And neither are we.

As long as we are walking in the Spirit, it is easy to fight off temptations. But the moment we start to rely on our own ability, is when sin hit us the most. I don’t believe I will ever kill anyone. But I struggle with my temper. I struggle with always doing what is ethical, especially when April 15th approaches. I really struggle obeying the speed laws. And when I try to control these areas of my life in my own power, is when Satan comes and attacks me the most.

Brothers & sisters, please listen to me, there is no way we can live our Christian lives without the help of the Spirit. That’s because Satan is such a dirty fighter, he is so subtle with sin, that he won’t just attack us with big sins. He also hits us with little sins.

And just like he did with Peter, he hit us when we lest expect it. I believe Peter was ready to face the Sanhedrin. I believe Peter was prepared to die for Jesus. But what he wasn’t ready for was an insignificant girl, who was in charge of the door, accusing him of being one of Jesus’ disciples. Have you ever noticed that most of the times we are tempted to sin is when we lest expect them? God told Cain that “Sin is crouching at the door; and its desire is for you.” (Genesis 4:7)

The lesson we learn from Peter is that instead of being independent, let’s stay inter-dependent upon God’s Spirit. Otherwise you will be trusting in the power of your flesh instead of the power of the Spirit to live the victorious Christian life. And the strength to make it safely through this world is not found in the flesh, but in the moment-by-moment dependence upon the power of the Holy Spirit.

As much as Jesus’ heart was broken by the Jews rejection of him, I don’t think his heart was broken nearly as much as when Peter denied him the third time. Not only did Jesus’ heart break by Peter’s denial, but when the rooster crowed, Peter’s heart was broken as well--v. 27.

When that happened these 2 scenes came together. Luke tells us that “At that moment the Lord turned and looked at Peter. Then Peter remembered that the Lord had said, ‘Before the rooster crows tomorrow morning, you will deny me three times.’ And Peter left the courtyard, crying bitterly.” (Luke 22:61-62)

The reason the Holy Spirit inspired John to include the story of Peter is that it beautifully portrays the grace of God. Later on in John’s gospel, Peter has the privilege of telling Jesus 3 times that he loves him. One time for each time Peter denied Jesus.

The message we see from Peter’s denial is that God is able to restore even the most wicked of all sinners. For despite the blatant atrocities of this illegal trial, they aren’t nearly as horrible as when Peter turned his back on Jesus at the time he needed him the most. If God can not only restore Peter, but also use him powerfully in his kingdom, don’t you think he can do that with you as well, no matter what sins you may have committed?

Let me close by saying that if you aren’t a Christian, there’s only one thing you need to do. That is to look into the face of Jesus. Let those eyes penetrate your heart and reveal to you your sins that put him on that cross. Then take another look into those eyes. This time see the love that’s in them that caused Jesus to willingly & joyfully go to that cross to pay off your debt of sin.

Or if you aren’t as close to Jesus as you once used to be, there’s also only one thing you need to do. That is to look again into the face of Jesus, and remember what it used to be like when you had a dynamic relationship with him. Let those eyes of love woo you back into loving him again.

RETURN TO THE ROAD TO THE CROSS SERIES INDEX