3. PILATE'S
INTERROGATION

John 18:28-40
(click to read the references)

The passage we are looking this morning, is the start of the day of what we now call Good Friday. The cover of night has passed as the dawn of a new day starts to appear on the horizon. The Jewish leaders have quickly & quietly led Jesus through the narrow streets of Jerusalem, to prevent an uprising from those who believed that Jesus was a mighty man sent from God, to the palace of the Roman governor, Pontius Pilate, while most of her inhabitants were still deep in sleep--v. 28.

Before they did so, while Jesus was still at Caiaphas' house, he had been spit upon, blindfolded, and punched repeatedly in the face by Caiaphas' men. The punches that do the most damage are what we call sucker punches. That is when someone hits you and you didn't see the blow coming.

Normally, if you see a punch coming your way, you have a chance to pull back your head so you don't feel the full blunt of the punch. But since Jesus was blindfolded, he wasn't able to pull back his head in defense. So by the time they brought Jesus to Pilate, he would have been bleeding profusely from his mouth, his nose, and his eyes, from all the blows he had received.

Though John doesn't tell us about this, I believe it is important for us to know, because it helps us to understand some of Pilate's reactions towards Jesus. With that in mind let's begin the next step of Jesus' journey to the cross, Pilate's interrogation, by looking first at the irony that John gives us in v. 28.

Notice that the Holy Spirit tells us that the Jewish leaders would not enter into the palace so they wouldn't defile themselves. I don't believe there is a more perverted scene in all of history than this one. These people had already defiled themselves by horribly abusing Jesus. They were in the middle of breaking God's most sacred law concerning the taking of another person's life. But in an attempt to appear holy, they wouldn't enter into a Gentiles home, for fear that they might come in contact with something that would keep them from being able to observe the Passover meal.

The irony we see in this is that the Jewish leaders should have recognized that Jesus was sent by God, but instead they wrongly reasoned he was sent by Satan. Instead of acknowledging that Jesus is the Lord of glory, the accuse him of being a vile criminal. Instead of confessing that Jesus is the Holy One of Israel, they condemned him as a blasphemer. Instead of embracing Jesus as the one who is the resurrection & the life, all they wanted to do was to execute the Lamb of God who was sent to save them from their sins. These Jewish leaders were straining so hard at a gnat, by trying to be careful not to break any of the Mosaic laws, that they ended up swallowing a camel, by plotting how to murder the one who gave the laws to Moses.

Because of their refusal to enter into Pilate's palace, Pilate is forced to go out to meet them--v. 29. As we look at Pilate over the next couple of sermons, we will see that Pilate believed that Jesus was innocent. Later on Pilate's wife sends a word to him to "Not do any harm to Jesus for he is an innocent man." (Matthew 27:19) But at this point, Pilate didn't have a clue as to what was going on. So, Pilate's question is a perfectly reasonable one. Because if he was going to sentence Jesus, there needed to be a legitimate charge.

Pilate's question puts a monkey wrench in their plans. The Jewish leaders make it perfectly clear that they don't want Pilate to have another trial. They are not asking him to do an investigation to see whether or not Jesus is a criminal. That's because they knew that they didn't have any evidence against Jesus that would warrant a crucifixion. All they want Pilate to do is to put his signature on the death sentence that they have already imposed on Jesus. So the question that Pilate asks them presents a problem to them. So in an attempt to sidestep the issue all together, the Jewish leaders begin to learn on Pilate--v. 30.

They can't believe that Pilate has the gall to question the legitimacy of them bringing Jesus before him. In essence they are accusing Pilate of slandering their righteousness. In their response, they were telling Pilate that he was about to make another political mistake, which Pilate couldn't afford to make.

In reality, what the Jewish leaders are doing is blackmailing Pilate. Which they had been doing to Pilate for some time now. Let me explain how they were able to do this by giving you some history concerning Pilate's dealings with the Jews.

The Jews had no love for Pilate even before he was made governor over Israel. That's because Pilate had aligned himself with those who promoted anti-Jewish policies throughout the Roman empire. And his viewpoints concerning the Jews were well known.

So not only did the Jews not trust him, but when he first came to Jerusalem, he brought into the city, flags & banners that had a sculptured image of Caesar on the tops of them. In those days, Caesar was not only the ruler of the Roman Empire, he was also worshipped as god. Which of course offended the Jews because they were not to worship any false idols or have any graven images of gods in their midst. Because of this, the Jews had been able to convince the other governors to take the sculptured images off of their flags & banners.

But Pilate didn't care what the Jews wanted. So when he came into Jerusalem carrying the flags & banners that had the image of Caesar on top of them, it led to an uprising with the Jews. In an attempt to squash the rioting, Pilate threatened to kill them all. But when the Jews told him to go ahead, Pilate backed down from killing them. And he also removed the images of Caesar. Pilate's first days in office was no honeymoon.

Then to make things worse, Pilate built an aqueduct using money he stole from the Temple. Again this didn't go over real well with the Jews. Once again the people started a riot. This time Pilate had his soldiers kill many of the Jews in order to stop the riots.

Now in an attempt to keep the peace of Rome throughout the world, Rome gave any of the people they ruled over the right to appeal any kind of wrongdoing to Caesar. So every time Pilate messed up, the Jews ratted him out to Caesar. The Caesar was getting tired of all the upheavals going on in the tiny nation of Israel, so he sent word back to Pilate that if he wanted to keep his job, he'd better not do anything else wrong.

The Jews knew that Pilate was close to losing his job, so they used this knowledge whenever they wanted to get their way. And now they were using it to have Pilate sentence the innocent Jesus to death by crucifixion. At this moment, Pilate has to decide whether it is more important to do what is right, or to play along with the Jews in order to keep his job. Notice that at first, Pilate doesn't play their game--v. 31. Pilate knows that according to Roman law, a criminal has to be given a trial that observes all the jurisprudence rules. The Roman legal system wasn't barbaric. It didn't allow for any kangaroo-court type of trials.

Which means that first of all a criminal has to be formally charged with a crime. Secondly, a criminal has to be given a fair trial where the charges against him are backed by evidence. And only after a criminal had been found guilty beyond what we call a shadow of a doubt, could a formal sentence can be given. But the Jewish leaders show that their only motive was to have Jesus executed.

It is interesting to note that Pilate has just given them permission to kill Jesus. He is signing Jesus' death warrant so the Jews have the permission of Rome to take Jesus and stone him to death. Once again Pilate is about to mess up their plans.

The Jewish leaders didn't want Jesus stoned to death. For one thing they would have to wait 2 more days to do so. And during that time the people would have found out about their illegal trial, and come to set Jesus free. So the Jewish religious leaders quickly tell Pilate that "We found this man perverting our nation, and forbidding us to give tribute to Caesar, and saying that he himself is Christ a king." (Luke 23:2)

Political treason and anarchy are charges worthy of death in a Roman court. Crimes that would cause the prisoner to be put to death immediately, for fear of their followers starting a riot to try to set them free. John quickly shows us that Jesus is not a common criminal, but the prophetic God--v. 32.

Jesus had earlier said, "And I, if I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all peoples to Myself. He said this to indicate how He was going to die." (John 12:32-33) The only way people die from being lifted up is to be crucified on a cross. So hours before, Jesus told his disciples that he was going to be killed by being crucified.

The Jews had already tried to kill Jesus by stoning him. But Jesus walked away. He walked away because if the Jews had killed him by stoning, they would have killed him on the ground. Which would have stopped him from fulfilling his destiny. But now, Jesus is ready to fulfill the purpose of why he came to this earth. Paul spoke of Jesus' destiny when he said, "Jesus Christ redeemed us from the curse of the Law, having become a curse for us--for it is written, 'Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree.'" (Galatians 3:13-14)

Pilate knew that the only reason the Jewish leaders wanted to kill Jesus was because Jesus had made them look bad on several occasions. So in an attempt to let Jesus go, Pilate questions Jesus himself--v. 33. When Pilate questions Jesus, there is an air of contempt in his voice. In the Greek it reads, "You, you're the king of the Jews?" As Pilate looks at this man, who had been beaten up by the hands of Caiaphas' men, he can't believe his eyes. What Pilate is literally saying to Jesus is, "Those Jews have got to be kidding if they expect me to believe that you are a king!"

We can't be too hard on Pilate here. After all, Jesus didn't look much like any kings he had ever seen. Jesus wasn't wearing fancy clothes. He wasn't surrounded by a court of servants.

Instead, he stood in front of Pilate, all alone, hands bound, bleeding profusely from his head, and wearing a peasant's robe. So Pilate's initial assessment of Jesus is that it is impossible for him to be a king. Even the king of the people he hated the most, the Jews.

Some of you here this morning may be just like Pilate. Perhaps you've seen the movie The Passion, or someone has been talking to you about Jesus, and you've come to investigate who Jesus is. If that is you, then you are doing the right thing. But I want you to know that if you think you are in control of your life, you're sadly mistaken.

That was Pilate's mistake. All of us, just like Pilate, have within our heart a desire to rule the kingdom of our own life. But the message of the Bible is clear: Jesus Christ came to be the King over our lives.

Jesus didn't die on the cross to play second fiddle in anyone's life. He is the exalted King, who wants to be the lord of all your life! If Jesus isn't the Lord of all, then perhaps he isn't your Lord at all. His kingship, his lordship, is proven by the way you live your life. Look next at the discussion that goes on between Jesus & Pilate--v. 34-36.

Jesus response is a legitimate response, because if Pilate is trying to see if Jesus is a political leader who is trying to overthrow the Romans, then the answer is no. But if Pilate is asking if Jesus is the promised Messianic Redeemer of the Jews, then the answer is yes. All Jesus is trying to do is to see what exactly is in Pilate's mind.

Pilate didn't like Jesus response. In Pilate's response we see that Jesus has never done anything that caused him to be on the Roman's watch list of known terrorists. Jesus had never said anything that might hint he was trying to start a revolution. Jesus had never done one single thing that might have caused Rome to be concerned about him.

But Pilate seems to be getting impatient & aggravated with the whole situation. It is obvious to Pilate that Jesus had done something to get the Jewish leaders so upset. But twice now he has tried to find out what, once from the Jews, and secondly from Jesus, but to no avail. So Pilate does the same thing the Jews did earlier: He asks Jesus what he had done wrong.

It was just as illegal for Pilate to do this as it was for the Jewish leaders. For just like the Jewish legal system, the Romans had established a law that forbid anyone from testifying against himself. This is why Jesus avoids Pilate's question and instead explains the kingdom he rules over. Jesus explains that his kingdom is not a physical kingdom, like Pilate viewed the Roman empire. Jesus' kingdom is a spiritual kingdom. This was part of the reason why the Jews rejected Jesus as their Messiah.

Most of the Jews were looking for a Messiah who would set up a physical & a political kingdom, rather than a spiritual kingdom. That will occur when Jesus rules from Jerusalem at the end of the Tribulation period. But at this time in history, Jesus is not interested in being a political king. He is not interested at this moment of being the king over a geographical region of the world. That's because his kingdom is global.

Since this is an election year, we need to be concerned about who we elect into office. For they have the authority to pass laws that will either promote righteousness or perpetuate the wickedness that is so prevalent in our land. But as hard as it is to imagine, at this time in history, Jesus is not even concerned about changing the laws of the land. Jesus' only concern is spiritually transforming the hearts of sinners into saints, which happens when people who make him their lord. This was the kind of transformation that needed to take place within Pilate's heart. The kind of transformation that would have taken place if he had listened more to the warnings of his wife, then to the ravings of the Jewish leaders.

Pilate thought it was quite funny to think that this Jewish peasant considered himself to be a king. So once again he asks a question that has a tinge of sarcasm in it as he looks upon this prisoner. But Jesus quickly lets Pilate know that he has finally got one thing correct: He is a king!--v. 37 The reason that Pilate didn't immediately have Jesus put to death, which he legally could have done, is because Jesus posed no threat to Rome. Pilate knew that although Jesus thought he was a king, he wasn't trying to establish his kingdom over the Romans. And indeed Pilate was right.

Jesus didn't come to set people free from the hands of the Roman government. He came to set people free from the shackles of sin. He came to seek and to save those who are lost. He came to give his life as a ransom for sinners. The answer of why Jesus came into the world is clear: He came to bear our sins in his own body on the cross, so that we can be brought into a relationship with God. The question we must all answer is this: Is Jesus Christ your king? If he is then you are to live each moment in submission to his lordship. You are to honor him with your lips & your life, every second of every day, for the rest of your life.

In Jesus' statement he also shows us his duel nature: God & man. Jesus was born of a woman whose name was Mary, in the city of Bethlehem. But his birth was unique for he was conceived in his mother's womb by the Holy Spirit. This truth is verified by the fact that his mother was a still a virgin at the time he was born.

Jesus goes on to tell us that he came into the world. He is talking about his pre-existence. If he came to the world, he had to come from somewhere else.

Over 20 years ago, I came to Aiken from California. This means that before I lived in Aiken, I lived in California. Jesus is telling us that before he lived in this world, he lived somewhere else first. And where was Jesus living before he moved to earth?

Earlier that evening, when Jesus was talking to his father, he said, "And now, Father, bring Me into the glory We shared before the world began." (John 17:5) The place Jesus lived before he moved to earth was heaven. Again the Holy Spirit makes sure that we know that Jesus is none other than Infinite God

Jesus concludes his remarks to Pilate by telling of the only evidence that indicts that someone has been born again. He told Pilate that those who are of the truth hear his voice. The Greek word "hear" means to listen intently and obey. You can't claim that the truth has set free sin if you aren't obeying Jesus' commandments. Jesus said that "Sheep follow their shepherd: for they know his voice." (John 10:4)

The evidence that you are born again is not whether or not you go to church. It is not whether or not you pray. It is not whether or not you have been baptized. It is not whether or not you read your Bible. It is not even whether or not you tithe. The only evidence of being born again is if you are following Jesus' voice.

A lot of people today claim they believe in Jesus, but their lives don't match their lips. The same was true in Jesus' day. Which is why Jesus said, "You are truly my disciples if you keep obeying my teachings." (John 8:31) Once again Pilate responds with a note of cynicism--v. 38.

The reason I believe Pilate is responding with cynicism is that he doesn't try to investigate what truth is. Pilate's political position indicates that he would have been a highly educated man. Which means he would have spent a lot of time studying about the concept of truth. And his answer indicates that after all his years of trying to find what is truth, he has come to the conclusion that there is no truth. Pilate is just like a lot of people today who say there is no absolute truth.

If Pilate really was interested in knowing the truth , he would have entered into a discussion with Jesus over what is truth. But instead he leaves Jesus and goes out to tell the Jews that Jesus is innocent of all charges. And he gives them the choice of what they want to do with Jesus--vv. 39-40.

It appears that by this time the people who were in Jerusalem had come to see what was going on. And from Pilate's question, it appears that that Pilate really thought the Jews would pick Jesus over Barabbas. In Pilate's mind, this has to be a "Duh!" question. In Pilate's mind, he thought the people would say in response to his question, "DUH! Let's us think about that for a few minutes." I really believe that despite how much the Jewish leaders hated Jesus, Pilate thought the people would have chosen Jesus over Barabbas.

After all, just 5 days ago the majority of these same people had met Jesus as he was coming into Jerusalem. And they were waving palm branches, and laying there garments on the ground, yelling out, "Hosanna to the Son of David! Blessed is He who comes in the name of the LORD! Hosanna in the highest!" (Matthew 21:9) But really what Pilate is trying to do is to evade the necessity of making a decision about Jesus. Matthew tells us in his gospel that Pilate's dilemma was "What should I do with Jesus who is called the Messiah?" (Matthew 27:22)

In that respect, Pilate is like some of you this morning. You too really don't want to have to make a decision about who Jesus is. But just like Pilate couldn't take a neutral position about Jesus, neither can you.

Either you are going to make Jesus your king, or you are going to reject Jesus as some loser. Either you want to be saved, or you want to continue to be lost. Either you want to be spiritually alive, or you want to remain dead in your sins. The choice is yours.

The Bible tells us that "Whoever has the Son has life; whoever does not have the Son of God does not have life." (1 John 5:12) Jesus put it this way concerning believing in him for salvation: "He who believes in Him is not condemned; but he who does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God." (John 3:18)

So let me ask in conclusion, who is your king? Who/what rules over your life? Who or what has your chief affections? Whoever or whatever you are devoting most of your time, talents, and treasures on, is your king.

But have any of these kings really given you the fulfillment you've been looking for in life? Are the kings you have been serving only leaving you empty and desperate? If so, then let me invite you to look to King Jesus. Since his kingdom is not of this world, he can satisfy your every need.

All you have to do to enter this kingdom is to embrace Jesus as your lord. All you have to do is to ask him to wash away your sins through his blood he shed for you on the cross. You don't have to understand everything there is to know about God. Just simply come to him as a child and with child-like faith, ask for his forgiveness. If you will do that, I promise you on the authority of God's Word, that your sins will be forgiven, and you will become one of the King's kids.

RETURN TO THE ROAD TO THE CROSS SERIES INDEX